55–65%
Completion rate — contingency executive search
92–96%
Completion rate — retained executive search
28%
Contingency searches that result in a mis-hire
How the Two Models Work (and Why the Incentives Are Different)
| Dimension | Retained Search | Contingency Search |
|---|---|---|
| Payment structure | Fee paid in thirds: at signing, shortlist, placement | Fee paid only at placement |
| Exclusivity | Exclusive engagement | Often non-exclusive; multiple firms competing |
| Incentive alignment | Firm incentivized to find the right candidate | Firm incentivized to find the fastest-to-close candidate |
| Candidate quality | Passive candidates sourced directly | Primarily active candidates from databases |
| Process depth | Full brief, market mapping, evidence dossiers | Database search, CV screening, light assessment |
| Replacement guarantee | 90-day guarantee standard at quality firms | Rare; typically 60-day or none |
| CEO time required | Higher — structured involvement | Lower — but more iterations if wrong |
Outcome Data: Retained vs. Contingency for VP and C-Suite Hires
| Metric | Retained Search | Contingency Search | DIY / Internal |
|---|---|---|---|
| Search completion rate | 92%–96% | 55%–65% | 40%–55% |
| Time to accepted offer | 45–90 days | 90–160 days | 120–200 days |
| Offer acceptance rate | 88%–93% | 61%–72% | 55%–68% |
| 18-month retention rate | 75%–85% | 55%–65% | 50%–60% |
| Passive candidate sourcing rate | 70%–85% | 20%–35% | 10%–20% |
| Mis-hire rate | 12%–18% | 24%–32% | 30%–40% |
The Total Cost Comparison
Scenario: VP Sales hire at $280K OTE
| Cost Component | Retained (20–25%) | Contingency (25–30%) | DIY |
|---|---|---|---|
| Direct search fee | $56K–$70K | $70K–$84K (if successful) | $0 direct |
| Internal time cost (CEO + HR) | $15K–$25K | $25K–$40K | $60K–$120K |
| Vacancy cost (extra days) | $40K–$80K (30–50 days) | $100K–$200K (90–150 days) | $150K–$300K (120–200 days) |
| Mis-hire risk cost (probability-weighted) | $60K–$120K | $170K–$300K | $220K–$400K |
| Total expected cost | $171K–$295K | $365K–$624K (if needed twice) | $430K–$820K |
When Contingency Makes Sense
Contingency search is appropriate in specific circumstances:
- Director-level and below roles where the candidate pool is wide and active
- High-volume hiring where speed is more important than precision
- Roles where a mis-hire is recoverable within 3–6 months
- Companies with strong internal talent networks that need supplemental sourcing
For VP and C-suite roles — where the candidate pool is passive, the search complexity is high, and a mis-hire costs 12–24 months — contingency search is structurally misaligned.
The "No Upfront Fee" Trap
Contingency search is marketed as "no risk — you only pay if we place someone." The framing is misleading. The risk isn't in the fee — it's in the outcome. A contingency firm that places a VP Sales in 90 days who leaves at month 14 has cost you more than a retained firm that placed the right person in 45 days. The fee is not the cost. The outcome is the cost.
Is Your Search on Track?
We assess your mandate timeline and tell you where it's most likely to stall. 20 minutes, no pitch.
Begin Search Assessment →